Home / Questions / Evaluating Cherone Equipments Plans With Varying Risk for Increasing Its Production Capaci...
Evaluating Cherone Equipment's Plans With Varying Risk for Increasing Its Production Capacity Cherone Equipment, a manufacturer of electronic fitness equipment, wishes to evaluate two alternative plans for increasing its production capacity to meet the rapidly growing demand for its key product-the Cardio-cycle. After months of investigation and analysis, the firm has pruned the list of alternatives down to the following two plans, either of which would allow it to meet its forecast product demand.
Plan X Use current proven technology to expand the existing plant and semi-automated production line. This plan is viewed as only slightly riskier than the firm's current average level of risk.
Plan Y Install new, just-developed automatic production equipment in the existing plant to replace the current semi-automated production line. Because this plan eliminates the need to expand the plant, it is less expensive than Plan X, but it is believed to be far riskier because of the unproven nature of the technology.
Cherone, which routinely uses NPV to evaluate capital budgeting projects, has a cost of capital of 12%. Currently, the risk-free rate of interest is 9%. The firm has decided to evaluate the two plans over a 5-year period, at the end of which each production line would be liquidated. The relevant cash flows associated with each plan are summarized in the following table.
| PlanX | PlanY | |
| Initial Investment | $2,700,000 | $2,100,000 |
| Year | Cash inflows | Cash Inflows |
| 1 | $470,000 | $380,000 |
| 2 | 610,000 | 700,000 |
| 3 | 950,000 | 800,000 |
| 4 | 970,000 | 600,000 |
| 5 | 1,500,000 | 1,200,000 |
The firm has determined the risk-adjusted discount rate (RADR) applicable to each plan as shown in the following table.
| Plan |
Risk-adjusted Discount rate (RADR |
| X | 13% |
| Y | 15% |
Further analysis of the two plans has disclosed that each has a real option embedded within its cash flows.
Plan X Real Option: at the end of 3 years the firm could abandon this plan and install the automatic equipment, which by then would have a proven track record. This abandonment option is expected to add $100,000 of NPV and has a 25% chance of being exercised.
Plan Y Real Optional: Because plan Y does not require current expansion of the plant, it creates an improved opportunity for future plant expansion. This option allows the firm to grow its business into related areas more easily if business and economic conditions continue to improve. This growth option is estimated to be worth $500,000 of NPV and has a 20% chance of being exercised.
To Do
a. Assuming that the two plans have the same risk as the firm, use the following capital budgeting techniques and the firm's cost of capital to evaluate their acceptability and relative ranking.
(1) Net present value (NPV).
(2) The Internal rate of Return (IRR)
b. Recognizing the differences in plan risk, use the NPV method, the risk-adjusted discount rates (RADRs), and the data given earlier to evaluate the acceptability and relative ranking of the two plans.
c. Compare and contrast your finding in parts (a ) and(b ). Which plan would you recommend? Did explicit recognition of the risk differences between the plans affect this recommendation?
d. Use the real-options data given above for each plan to find the strategic NPV, NPVstrategic, for each plan.
e. Compare and contrast your findings in part d with those in part (b ). Did explicit recognition of the real options in each plan affect your recommendation?
f. Would your recommendations in parts(a ),(b ),and(d ) change if the firm were operating under capital rationing? Explain.
Apr 08 2020 View more View Less
GROUP ASSIGNMENT Problem 1 On October 1, 2018, Adriana Lopez launched a computers ervices company called Success Systems, which provides consulting services, computer sys...
May 09 2020For the function - esinx. 0
Apr 13 2021Suppose that the Melbourne's housing market is perfectly competitive (i.e., many real estate developers). The city government decides to introduce a buyer's tax (specific...
Mar 25 2020Cost of Goods Sold Slapshot Company makes ice hockey sticks. During the month of June, 18,000 sticks were completed at a cost of goods manufactured of $540,000. Suppose t...
Jun 27 2020Figure below to answer the question(s) that follow. answered Marked out of 1.00 P Flag question Number of lawns mowed per day 3 0 i 2 L Number of employees Figure Refer t...
Apr 05 2021Composite Filaments: MakerBot really pushed 3D ahead this year when it introduced several new composite filaments. These composite filaments combine traditional PLA (po...
Apr 11 2021Midwest Manufacturing purchased a three-year insurance policy for $30,000 on January 2, 2015. Prepare any journal entries, adjusting journal entries, and closing journal...
Aug 27 2020My utility is given by u(XI, X2)-2x10.1x21.2 + In(x) + [min(xl+ X2)]2 + 2x2 + x11.1. True, False, or Cannot Be Determined: When P1 = $2, P2-$4, and I consumption bundle i...
May 01 2020Cost Accounting Cycle Entries in T Accounts. At the beginning of October, the ledger of the Highlander Company contained (among other accounts) the following: Materials, ...
May 14 2020Assume the following data describes the gasoline market Price per gallon 2.00 2.25 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50 Quantity demand 36 35 34 33 32 31 30 Quantity supplied 24 26 2...
Jun 02 2020